Data Privacy Happenings 📰
Hello from MineOS's monthly newsletter, The Privacy Mindset! 👋
Vermont, that most beautiful green mountainous land of maple syrup, ben & jerry's, and black bears, seemingly had #19 locked down as the State Congress passed a comprehensive data privacy law, bill H.121, in May.
The state was all set to join the wave of privacy legislation that has swept the nation over the past year and a half, but instead, Vermont gains an infamous tag: the first state to have a privacy law vetoed by the governor.
So what happened? The private right of action.
Vermont's bill became just the second state other than California to feature a private right of action, meaning individuals can sue organizations for noncompliant behavior.
As you might imagine from that description, it's something businesses hate with the intensity of a thousand burning suns, having worked tirelessly over the years to lobby it out of the early stages of other states' draft privacy bills.
Those tactics did not work in Vermont, which for a brief fluttering moment exhilarated the privacy community. The moment was brief because the Vermont Governor, Phil Scott (R), immediately expressed reservations about signing the bill into law, even despite its overwhelming 139-3 margin in the Vermont House of Representatives.
Governor Scott did in fact veto the bill, claiming the state's business community would suffer under such onerous burdens. He insisted Vermont follow its fellow New England examples, as Connecticut and New Hampshire both have laws on the books (and Rhode Island just passed its own data privacy law as well), refusing to allow the state to venture away from the herd, even if that might set a positive example.
With the veto override vote failing in the state Senate and the legislature closed for the year, Vermont will need to wait until 2025 to reengage on a watered down privacy bill.
The main takeaway? Even with big progress in America on the issue of data privacy, we still have a long way to go to truly empower people online and stop the ensh*ttification of the internet.